Posts Tagged ‘charts’

Roller Coaster Ride in the San Francisco RE Market – Supply and Demand

There has suddenly been a lot of talk in the media about how, based upon December numbers, the housing market is faltering – and there’s talk of a “double-dip” and so on. Honestly, I have no idea what the future holds, but drawing big conclusions from 1 month’s data is nonsensical. In any case, here is the chart of SF listings going under contract that has been updated. December’s ratifications did fall from the autumn, as they always do, but comparing the numbers to not only last year (crash) but to 2007, we see that December 2009 was not particularly weak, at least not here in SF.

market_dynamics

San Francisco Luxury Homes Report: January 2010

San Francisco Luxury Homes Report

January 2010

The luxury home market in San Francisco consists of houses selling for $2,000,000 or more, and condos selling for $1,500,000 plus. This market bounced back from the crash that occurred in the 3 – 5 months after 9/15/08, but year over year, 2009 luxury house sales were still down about 33% from sales in 2007 and 2008, and luxury condo sales were down about 40% from 2008 and 50% from 2007. Financing became more difficult for upper-end homes and obviously economic conditions affected the market, but much of the drop in sales can be explained by the 15% – 20% drop in values that occurred, i.e., a fair number of homes that were in the luxury range simply no longer qualified as such. Indeed, 2009 sales numbers are quite similar to those in 2006 before values peaked. Depending on neighborhood, peak values for the luxury market usually occurred in 2007 and 2008.

 

As the number of sales have declined, the average days on market, the number of price reductions, and the number of listings withdrawn from the market without selling rose dramatically — all are signs of sellers and/or listing agents not wanting to recognize new pricing realities in the market.

 

Still, the luxury home market in San Francisco is very much alive, and of those homes that did sell in 2009, 35% – 40% accepted offers within 30 days of going on market, and on average closed within 3% – 4% of the original asking price. The demand isn’t as frantic as it was in previous years, but there is still strong demand for well priced luxury properties. A fair number is still receiving multiple offers and selling for over asking price. Values appear to have stabilized after their large drop, and may have – it’s too soon to be definitive – started to tick up in the last quarter.

 


The data above and below is from sources deemed reliable but may contain errors or omissions, and not warranted. Sales not reported to MLS (such as many new-development condo sales) are not reflected in these statistics. Median prices may fluctuate for other reasons besides changes in value.
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Change in SF Home Sales by Price Range
With the big changes in economic conditions, sales at the lower price ranges have strengthened and those at the higher have weakened. Many first time buyers entered the market in 2009 and they typically purchase less expensive homes. And the foreclosure home market is still predominately a feature of the low end of the market, clustered in the less affluent neighborhoods. Finally, lending conditions and tax credits are mostly geared to the low and mid range home.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Luxury Home Sales $2m and Above by Quarter
This chart shows home sales $2,000,000 and above. Here we can see the surge in sales that occurred in 2007 and 2008, the big drop after 9/15/08, and the subsequent recovery at numbers similar to those of 2006. The fourth quarter of 2009 will probably end up with 55 to 60 closed sales, generally consistent with the previous 2 quarters.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
SF Home Sales by Price Range
The luxury market by number of sales is a relatively small portion of the city market.
>>>For more information on the general SF real estate market
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Luxury House Sales by Neighborhood
High end houses are typically found in a handful of high prestige neighborhoods, which during the height of the market expanded to the Noe/Castro/Haight area. The northern neighborhoods around Pacific Heights have fared the best in 2009, with barely a budge in overall sales numbers. Other areas saw large declines.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Luxury House Sales by Realtor District
The city is divided into 10 districts by the Association of Realtors. Some districts are more homogeneous in values, such as districts 5 and 7, while other districts contain neighborhoods of wildly varying value (district 8 includes both Russian Hill and the Tenderloin). Here is another snapshot of how those areas with significant luxury house sales fared year over year.
>>>Realtor District Map of SF
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Luxury Condo Sales by Neighborhood
The SF luxury condo market stretches east from Sea Cliff across the northern neighborhoods to Telegraph Hill, then south around the edges through the Financial District, South Beach and SOMA. Virtually of them, except for Russian Hill, saw large declines in the number of sales. The luxury condo market, like the condo market in general, has been more negatively affected by market changes than the house market.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Luxury Condo Market by Realtor District
Four of the city’s 10 districts dominate the luxury condo market. Here is how they fared year over year. As with luxury houses, district 5, a relative new-comer to the luxury home arena, was most dramatically affected. Again, this analysis only covers those sales reported to MLS. Many new-condo development sales, most of which occur in district 9, are not included. For example, the largest condo sale of 2009 was the penthouse of the Millennium in South Beach, which closed, outside of MLS, for over $9,000,000. Paragon was pleased to represent the buyer.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Average Days-on-Market for Luxury Homes
Days on market in this chart measures the number of days between a property going on market and it being designated as “pending sale, contingencies removed.” As one can see, the figure has increased dramatically over the past year.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Expired Luxury Home Listings
With the market change, more luxury home listings are being withdrawn from the market without selling, typically due to being perceived as overpriced. The fourth quarter of the year generally sees a large surge as listings expire on December 31st. Many will be re-listed again in January.
 
 

 

 

January 2010 Update: Real Estate in San Francisco

The data below is from sources deemed reliable but may contain errors or omissions, and is not warranted. Sales not reported to MLS (such as many new-development condo sales) are not reflected in these statistics. Median prices may fluctuate for other reasons besides changes in value.
Paragon Real Estate Group
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
SF Median Home Price by Property Type
Depending on neighborhood, SF home values peaked in 2006, 2007 or 2008, then declined dramatically in the 2nd half of 2008 (especially after 9/15/08), and then recovered (somewhat) with the surge in sales that began in spring of 2009. The increase in TIC median price in the 4th quarter of 2008 and the 1st quarter of 2009 is an anomaly: very few sales occurred and they do not reflect the reality that TIC values also fell during this period. (A good example of how median prices can fluctuate.) The main point of the chart is the stability of house and condo median prices in the 2nd and 3rd quarters of 2009, and the uptick seen in the 4th quarter. It is too soon to reach definitive conclusions, but it appears that buyer demand is fueling a small increase in values.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
SF Home Sales by Realtor District
There are 10 Realtor districts in the city (see map link below). The districts with the most house sales are district 10, the southern less affluent neighborhoods which have been battered by foreclosure sales, district 2, Sunset-Parkside, and district 5, the Noe/Castro/Haight cluster of neighborhoods. Condo sales are concentrated in 9, SOMA/South Beach/Potrero Hill (and this graph doesn’t include the many new development sales that occur outside of MLS in this district), in 8, the greater Russian/Nob/Telegraph Hills area, and 5, Noe/Castro/Haight. The big district for TIC sales is also 5.
>>>Realtor District Map
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
SF Home Sales Percentage by Property Type
Houses make up the largest portion of home sales, followed by condos. The house market has held up best in terms of unit sales since the big market changes began in 2008.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
SF Home Sales by Price Range
The biggest home market in the city is the $500,000 to $750,000 range and its number of sales was stable in 2008 and 2009. The below $500,000 market saw the biggest increase in sales (over 40%), year over year, fueled in particular by distressed property sales in district 10 (Bayview-Excelsior). All the price ranges above $750,000 saw major drops in unit sales (20% – 40%), year over year – with the declines increasing with every step up in price.
>>>Foreclosure & Short Sale Analysis
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
SF Luxury House Sales by Neighborhood
High-end houses are typically found in a handful of high prestige neighborhoods, which during the height of the market expanded to the Noe/Castro/Haight area. The northern neighborhoods around Pacific Heights fared best in 2009, with barely a budge in overall sales numbers. Other areas saw large declines.
>>>Complete Luxury Home Report
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
SF Median House Price by Neighborhood
The most valuable houses in the city are in the high-prestige northern neighborhoods running from Sea Cliff to Russian Hill, though most of them still have too few sales for a median price to be meaningful (Pacific Heights is an exception). Then come houses in the Noe/Castro/Haight area and St. Francis Wood. The least valuable are in the less affluent southern border neighborhoods — Bayview in particular has been hammered by the foreclosure crisis. House sizes can vary hugely by neighborhood: some known for their large mansions, others populated by classic 2-bedroom 1940′s homes; others with a mix of every type and size of house possible.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
SF House Average Dollar per Square Foot
Sometimes dollar per square foot is in lockstep with median prices, such as in the prestige northern neighborhoods, but other times it alters the order of value. For example, the median price for a St. Francis Wood house is higher than a Noe Valley house, but the average dollar per square foot value is significantly higher in Noe. But St. Francis Wood are typically much larger and, generally speaking, the larger a house, the less the dollar per square foot it generates.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
SF Median Condo Price by Neighborhood
The most expensive condos in the city are found either in the northern neighborhoods — especially Pacific Heights, Russian and Nob Hills — or in upper floor units of new high-end developments in the financial district, South Beach and SOMA. The median condo prices for some of these areas don’t imply their luxury sales simply because of the sheer quantity of sales at lower price ranges. Russian Hill condos have held their value better than virtually any other property type and location in the city.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
SF Condo Average Dollar per Square Foot
Again, Russian Hill comes out on the top of the scale. These most expensive condos in the city can sell for $1500 to $2000 per square foot. Remember that some neighborhoods have parts that are as exclusive as any in the city and other parts that are much less desirable: Nob Hill is a good example of this. This can play havoc with median and average figures, depending on what sells when.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
3-Bedroom House Price Trend Chart
Districts 2 (Sunset/Parkside) and 5 (Noe/Castro/Haight) were chosen for this analysis simply because they have a lot of house sales, which makes the data more reliable. This chart implies a stabilization of district 5 house prices after a large drop (after 9/15/08), and a fairly large uptick in median price in district 2. Since median prices fluctuate for other reasons besides value, one shouldn’t read too much into the sudden 7% jump in district 2.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
2-Bedroom Condo Price Trend Chart
These 3 areas were chosen because of their large number of condo sales. The most interesting aspect of this chart is that all 3 show an uptick in median price for 2-bedroom condos. Yet more evidence for a general increase in values. We’ll see if it continues or stabilizes in 2010.
Contact me for more information regarding the SF real estate market at 415.863.Katy(5289) or Katy@KatyDinner.com

Highest 30 yr Mortgage Rates Hit in Oct 1981…They were 18.45%!!!

After touching the lowest levels on record before Thanksgiving, rates are now about .1% higher than that. The attached chart shows rates from December 2009 back to April 1971, when Freddie Mac started officially tracking 30 year mortgage rates. The high was in October 1981, when borrowers paid an average of 2.3% points to buy a rate down to 18.45%. The low was November 25, 2009, when borrowers averaged 0.7% points to buy a rate down to 4.78%—note that 4.78% with 0.7% points was also achieved April 2 and April 30, 2009. These are rates on conforming loans up to $417,000 for single family homes with 20% or more equity in the property.

Mortgage interest rates have been, and continue to be, some of the lowest interest rates in recorded history…Contact Julian or I, to discuss why now could be the best time for you to buy.

Visit us on the web at: Katy or JulianRates1971to2009_jdh

Year-end Charts & Graphs on the San Francisco RE Market

2009 Wrap-up: Real Estate in San Francisco


It has been an interesting year in real estate, and it continues to be a very interesting time for home buyers and sellers in San Francisco. Below are a number of charts which review the city’s market from a variety of angles.


The data below is from sources deemed reliable but may contain errors or omissions, and is not warranted. Sales not reported to MLS (such as many new-development condo sales) are not reflected in these statistics.

 

        

Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
San Francisco Foreclosure Sales by Neighborhood
As has been the case since the foreclosure crisis began, the majority of bank-owned (REO) house sales occur in the city’s less affluent, southern border neighborhoods running from Oceanview to Bayview-indeed, a little more than half of all house sales in those neighborhoods are either REO or short sales. For REO condos, the main neighborhoods are SOMA, South Beach and Mission Bay, where most recent condo development has taken place. For a much fuller analysis of foreclosure and short sales in San Francisco:
SF Foreclosure Sales & Short Sales Analysis
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Home Appreciation & Depreciation in San Francisco since 1995
This chart graphs the changes in median price for 3-bedroom houses selling at various points over the past 15 years in selected neighborhoods. Remember that median prices are generalities which can fluctuate for a number of reasons, and may or may not reflect values for any particular property. The complete analysis, which includes condos and TICs can be found here:
Appreciation & Depreciation since 1995
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
San Francisco Median Home Prices
The median home price (house and condo) in the city has been remarkably stable, running between $685,000 and $710,000 from April through October 2009, then ticking up to $731,000 in November. This is after the general 15% to 25% decline in values from their times of peak value. (The southern neighborhoods hit hard by foreclosures have seen 25% – 40% declines.) In comparison, in 2007, the median home price in the city hit $829,000. It is too soon to tell if November’s increase in median price is the beginning of a trend or just an anomalous blip.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Mortgage Rates Hit All-Time Low
Loan interest rates are such a vital part of the home-purchase affordability equation because of their impact on both qualifying for a loan and the ongoing monthly cost of home ownership. Interest rates hit at all time low in late November. It’s harder to qualify than in past years, but if you can qualify, the rates are fantastic. Many analysts expect interest rates to jump by at least 1 percentage point in 2010. (The attached chart was provided by Julian Hebron of RPM Mortgage.)
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Listings Accepting Offers
More listings accepted offers in October than in any month in the past 2 years. Business began to taper off in November, which is common for the holidays, but the number of accepted offers was still higher than in November 2008 or 2007. Buyer demand remains quite strong and homes perceived as good values are selling quickly. The holiday season is actually a good time to make offers because there isn’t as much competition from other buyers and sellers are eager to move on with their lives.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Homes for Sale
The number of active listings for sale normally decline in November and December, and then pick up again in January, but there is still a fair amount of inventory available.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Months-Supply-of-Inventory (MSI)
MSI is a calculation of how many months it would take to sell the existing inventory of homes for sale at the current rate of sale. At 3.4 months, the MSI for San Francisco homes is about as low as at any time in the past 2 years. There is certainly no glut of homes for sale.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Listings That Do Not Sell
Comparing this chart to the earlier chart of homes accepting offers, we see that for every 2 listings that sell, about one listing expires without selling. Not reflected on this chart are listings withdrawn from the market by their sellers before the listing period expires, usually because they are not generating “acceptable” offers. Unlike the hot market of earlier years, not all listings sell nowadays; only those that are perceived as good values are selling. Listings perceived as overpriced sit on the market for months (or years) until finally expiring or being withdrawn.
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Federal Tax Credit Extended and Improved
The Federal Homebuyers’ Tax Credit is one of several major factors that have fueled the resurgence in sales – the other main factors being low interest rates and the decline in prices. Attached is an outline, put together by the National Association of Home Builders, of the basics of the $6500 – $8000 tax credit. The NAHB also has the most extensive FAQ sections on the details of the program:
Federal Tax Credit FAQs
 
Paragon Real Estate Group

click for larger image
Return on Investment: SF Real Estate vs. Stock Market
Obviously, the comparison shown on this chart depends wholly on the period of the analysis, but considering that real estate values have generally dropped 15% – 25% over the past year or two, and that the stock market is way up for the year, it doesn’t seem unfair to look at return on investment over the past 10 years.
When is the time to buy?
 

 

         

Listings Going Under Contract Declining

Declining from September’s large burst of activity (though still at decent levels of activity) – scale starts at 75, not zero:

undercontract

For every 10 solds, 5 – 8 are expiring without selling

Homes sold vs homes expiring by week through 9-20-09: recently, for every 10 solds, 5 – 8 are expiring without selling:

expired

Home listing coming on the market still very high

New listings coming on market by week through 9-20-09 (scale starts at 80, not at 0):

newlistings

Pick up in ratified deals since 9-14-09, but not substantially higher than August

Homes going under contract by week through 9-20-09 (scale starts at 80, not at 0): big pick up in ratified deals since 9-14-09, but not substantially higher than August.

undercontract

2100 for sale now vs 2400 in early June

Total homes for sale by week through 9-20-09 (scale starts at 1750, not 0): 2100 for sale now vs 2400 in early June.

forsale